5 Essential Elements of a Converting Website

Converting Website

Have your website visitors gone radio silent? There’s a possibility that your website isn’t out of commission: It might just be too confusing to convert.

To see if your website has the essential elements to be effective in bringing in leads, answer these five questions. As an advocate of StoryBrand methodology for creating websites, I will use some of their language.

1. Does your website effectively lay out your product/service and the benefits for the customer?

Humans are hardwired to survive and thrive. You need to demonstrate to customers how your product or service can do just that. This crucial piece of website creation is called the “grunt test” in the StoryBrand methodology. Does your website answer these questions in a way that’s simple enough for a caveman to understand?

  • What product/service are you selling?
  • How does it benefit the consumer?
  • How can the consumer buy it?

The grunt test is no joke for a successful converting website. You must answer these three questions within just a few seconds of a visitor glancing at your page. Cut to the chase with clear language that clarifies what you do, how it can help and how the visitor can benefit from partnering with you on their journey.


Essential Website Element 1: Effectively lay out your offering(s) and how to purchase them.

2. Is the hero of your website the customer?

You might think that your company or product is the hero of the story you’re trying to convey to website visitors, but it’s actually the opposite. Your customer is the hero and you are the guide; after all, it’s the customer’s story that you’re telling. In this story, the customer faces a challenge that they can’t solve on their own; that’s where you come in. (Think Professor Dumbledore and Harry Potter.) To demonstrate that the customer is the hero, and in turn capture their attention, your website needs to talk about their personal challenges and how you are the guide to provide them with the appropriate solution.


Essential Website Element 2: Designate the customer as the hero and yourself as the guide.

3. Are there consistent calls to action (CTAs) on every page?

Every good hero has to take action to solve their problem. In much the same way, your customer must be challenged to take an action via CTAs on your website. These can be embedded within text or placed on standalone buttons. Having a clear, compelling call to action ensures your customer doesn’t get confused and click off your page.

The most effective CTAs are filled with action words. Some strong examples are “Book a Meeting,” “Schedule a Review” and “Get a Free Quote.” Be sure to repeat them across your homepage and on other pages, too. A bold CTA button should always be in the upper right navigation of the site.

Essential Website Element 3: Craft and design CTAs worth clicking on.

4. Is your website authentic?

Your website should give visitors a clear picture of who they could be working with. Images should be authentic to show customers who they are interacting with. It’s not too difficult for people to identify stock images, which can be a major turnoff. The best way to show your staff in their best light is by scheduling an office photoshoot. Thanks to modern websites like Snappr Photography (our personal recommendation) or Thumbtack, photoshoots aren’t as overwhelming as they may seem. You can hire and schedule a photographer who is located in one of the platform’s long list of cities.

Essential Website Element 4: Be authentic with images of your team and office.

5. Is your website professional looking and easy to navigate?

Customers want a credible service, and a tacky, confusing website doesn’t appeal to most. If your competitor offers the same services, the one with the easy-to-navigate website will get major bonus points. 

A great way to appeal to visitors is showing that you have helped people with problems just like theirs. Testimonials, case studies and industry pages provide tangible examples that customers can relate to. For example, a law firm representative visiting an IT company’s website wants to know that the company can help the firm understand the compliance regulations of their industry.

One of the most important pages on a converting website is the home page. The design should be professional in appearance and represent your brand (team photos, appropriate colors, designated fonts). Make sure it gives clear paths to your services and industry pages. It’s a good idea to include testimonials on the home page so visitors don’t have to look far to find another person who was in the same situation as them.

Essential Website Element 5: Have a professional, credible website with well thought-out navigation.

6. Bonus: Is your website optimized for search engines (SEO)?

You can have the best story told through simple and clear messaging on all your webpages, but if search engines don’t know the site exists, your efforts are futile. SEO involves optimizing your core pages (Home, Services, Industries) for search, in conjunction with a robust content plan. SEO is based on keywords; each page of your website should be optimized for a specific keyword. Services like Google’s Keyword Planner can help you decide which keywords to use based on your target area.

The best way to consistently share content on your site is through a blog. Each blog post is also optimized for a keyword, which should be a long-tail version of words used on your individual pages. Planning a blog posting schedule is a methodical way to be found among your competitors.

Using blog posts to drive traffic to your website and increase conversions is a powerful form of content marketing. You should be sharing relevant and educational content that isn’t salesy. Visitors will find your article by doing a search for the product or service you offer, so they will be interested in the topic regardless of what stage in the buyer’s journey they are in. If they enjoyed reading your blog post, they may begin to peruse other pages of your site. Blog posts should include a CTA and a tie back to your offerings, especially at the end.

SEO is a process that takes time to develop; rising up through search results rankings doesn’t happen overnight. Be intentional with every piece of content you share. Two to three pieces of content per week is the ideal target, but starting with just one post a week is fine.

Other content formats you may want to share on your website include case studies, testimonials, e-books, infographics and videos. These can be created using simple editing tools like Canva or Adobe. Their educational nature is perfect for common search queries and can capture potential leads.

Essential Website Element 6: Optimize your website with SEO strategies and create a content plan.

Streamline the Process Using a Cheat Sheet

This website cheat sheet includes 23 questions that Google asks when its crawlers evaluate your website, plus the five we examined above. If you’re a more visual person, you can watch our webinar on SEO optimization to make Google love you.

Looking for Website Conversion Help?

Are you ready to convert your website visitors into marketing qualified leads? Our BigOrange Marketing team has built a converting website ranking at the top of search engine results for over a dozen clients. We have content experts, website designers and programmers that are happy to help you build or redesign your website. Schedule a free 30-minute consultation with me to learn more.

Margee Moore

Margee Moore

I'm the CEO + Digital Marketing Strategist at BigOrange Marketing. I’m passionate about helping companies to clarify their messaging to get leads and grow.

Share the knowledge

Social Media LinkedIn

How to Create Engaging LinkedIn Posts in Bulk

Ready to get real results and enhance your social media marketing on LinkedIn with share-worthy content that aligns with your brand values? Join us for…

Explore this Topic
effective social media posts

What Types of Social Media Posts Are Most Effective?

There are a lot of choices and directions you can go in when you look at all the types of social media posts, designs and…

Explore this Topic
How to Build a Converting MSP Website

Turbo-charge Your MSP Website: Unlock the Power of Lucky 13

Managed service providers, want to transform your MSP website into a powerhouse of conversion?   Here are 13 essential points that will elevate your website’s performance…

Explore this Topic
Manufacturing Marketing Prospective Customers

How Prospective Customers Evaluate Manufacturers

Did you know that your next marketing breakthrough as a manufacturer could be hidden within the buying behaviors of prospective customers? The Shift From Handshakes…

Explore this Topic
Why is Social Media Topic Authority Important? Business Social Made Simple

Why Is Social Media Topic Authority Important?

Today’s marketing landscape is crowded. Every industry I can think of is full of firms that have a longer tenure, more capital and resources. Topic…

Explore this Topic
What Is a Social Media Hook? Business Social Made Simple

What Is a Social Media Hook?

I hardly remember anything or even care when I first see it. Yet I keep coming back and checking in and engaging on my social…

Explore this Topic
Turbocharge Your Google Rankings with 7 Easy Tips!

Turbocharge Your Google Rankings with 7 Easy Tips!

Unleash the untapped potential of Google My Business (GMB). Learn how in our electrifying webinar. All of these tips will be delivered in our super-efficient,…

Explore this Topic
HubSpot Sales Processes to Adopt

8 Ways to Use HubSpot Sales Process Tools

HubSpot sales process tools are often overlooked but can be powerful, no matter if you have a  sales team of one, 10 or 100. The…

Explore this Topic

The 22 Best Digital Marketing Ideas to Drive Sustainable Lead Generation in 2024


Ready to grow in 2024? A good plan has to be comprehensive and filled with the best ingredients--from SEO to content, social media to paid boosting. 

Here’s what you’ll learn:

  • How to target efficiently with personas
  • How to assess if your website is hurting or helping you
  • How a content marketing plan will help you rank with Google through SEO
  • The social media tactics you need and the ones you can skip